Tuesday, November 27, 2007

Section Seven

7.1 Brown, J.S., Duguid, P. (1989). Situated Cognition and the Culture of Learning. Educational Researcher, 18(1), 32-42.

This article details many aspects of learning that need to be implemented in order to allow children to learn more holistically and naturally. And I do not know if this is purely because I went to a Blue Ribbon School of Excellence, but I feel as if the arguments are outdated. My high school encouraged taking all types of learning into consideration and in many classes we were offered numerous ways of conducting assignments. Group projects occurred at least once every single course. In my math courses we visited the computer lab to utilize software that is used in the mathematics industry. Brown and Duguid indicate that schools are not doing this, and therefore, not allowing students to learn properly. I just do not agree with that sentiment.

That aside, I do find this article to be a helpful collection of ideas that will allow me to become a better teacher. In detailing a study conducted by Lampert, the authors highlight that "allowing students to generate their own solution paths" is an excellent way to engage and interact with solving the problem. One of the articles I encountered for my paper detailed children being instructed on how to utilize metadata to emphasize their searches, yet repeatedly chose to look at book covers instead. I feel that by having students map out the way they would search for information, and not simply having the media specialist drilling search methods into their heads, students will take more of the information away from the library with them. Not to say that the information will become completely ingrained and they are future librarians after this method, but it does seem to be more interactive, and therefore, more likely to stick with the children.

Thursday, November 22, 2007

Section Twelve

12.2 Dilevko, Juris. (2000). "My mother can't quite understand why I decided to go to library school" What patrons say about library staff when asking government documents reference questions at depository libraries. Journal of Government Information, 27 (299-323).

The findings of this article almost made me want to work in a depository library, just to improve the quality of customer service. I was appalled by some of the behaviors exhibited by those in my field. As I was reading this article I am certain that I made enough outraged gasps to sufficiently annoy those in the general surrounding area. I was just unable to control it, considering that multiple librarians found it appropriate to ignore patrons. That many of these reference interviews took place in an area intended specifically for government documents makes these reactions even more disturbing.

While this article certainly caused a shock, I am not certain exactly how to read this. The author's intention comes across portraying the current library field as one that does not care about patrons with the effort of shocking librarians to do a better job. As described in the previous paragraph, that was indeed my initial reaction. However, on a closer inspection I don't know how reliable that actually is. The information detailing the data and research methods is unclear and jumbled. It is not until the results section that I even found out there were 30 participating proxies. Considering the amount of questions that were asked to different libraries (a total of 488) it is necessary to contrast that with the amount of proxies. The average number of questions asked per proxy is 16 questions. While it is possible that these Canadian librarians are actually that atrocious, it is also equally possible that the library students were overloaded by asking questions. If that is the case, an agitated mood could influence the results, as people do not wish to interact with grumpy people. Yes, librarians should willingly help all people, even the agitated, but it would be more understandable for a librarian to be rude to a rude person.

Sunday, November 4, 2007

Children’s Categorization Abilities and the Future of the School Library

Abstract:

This paper examines the information needs and behaviors of children from kindergarten through the sixth grade. It begins with a discussion of the ways this group sets out to fill their information voids, especially in a digital environment. Through this lens, the discussion moves towards children’s behaviors as a result of their cognition, examining the categorization abilities of children. How these notions differ from traditional library categories is important in understanding why children do not often utilize keywords and metadata. In the crux between the traditional library and the new library 2.0, it is important to reflect upon the limited research available describing user-driven tagging and the place it may have in alleviating the tensions children associate with searching using current categories.

1. Introduction/General User Description

a. Cognitive Ability of User
b. Searching Methods
c. Application of Models to the Understanding of User

2. Categorization Skills of User/Literature Review

a. Psychology Literature
b. LIS Literature
  • i. Cooper
    ii. Cooper
    iii. Bilal

3. Web 2.0

a. Folksonomies
    • i. Definition
      ii. Review of Literature/Application to User

4. Implications for School Librarians

a. User-driven Library Categories
b. Personalized Digital Library

Saturday, October 20, 2007

Section Eight

8.1

When I am bored, I spend my time looking up new and interesting rules and nuances in the English language. This hobby often produces a slight tendency to revise authors' statements as I read their work. In Pettigrew's article, I found the occasional lack of proper grammatical rules to impede my reading to the point where I must include this criticism. I am aware that this does not bear heavily on the content presented in the article, but it makes me reluctant to take her seriously. I would have ignored the lack of commas, even though this led to many confusing clauses that caused me to reread sentences frequently. I would have, that is, until I came across the term "clinics" (p. 806), where the possessive form of the word is lacking the proper apostrophe, or any apostrophe at all, for that matter. Comma errors are frequent in many papers produced outside of the field of English and Language Arts and are sadly expected. This error, however, is unacceptable and attacks the credibility of the author and whichever members of the scholarly community that reviewed this article before publication.

That being said, this article actually brought me to a better understanding of context than the articles written solely to describe context. The author began the article by including the definition of context taken from the dictionary. While this may be more simplistic than one studying information behavior would like to work with, it is a graspable foundation within which to begin. From there, the author then applied context in four situations and presented specific examples relating back to these subcategories. These applications of context provided better models for me to understand this concept than confusing lists of what context is and is not. It explicitly shows context as physical surroundings, such as hospital curtains (p. 805). Once I read that, it seemed obvious that these curtains would influence the flow of personal information. It is not until after these two actions that the author begins to discuss current trends and theories relating to context. I was able to put context into... context.

Based on my new understanding of context, I can visualize my future in librarianship differently. By breaking up context into subcategories and then reflecting on it as a whole I can figure out exactly what type of atmosphere I would like to create in the media center and focus on the steps to get there. Would I want a more studious environment or one that was more conducive to pleasure reading? Or would I like to have different sections that produce different atmospheres? As one of the first librarians my future students will meet, it is my job to make sure the library is an inviting and welcoming place. This article provided me with a new way of seeing the work I have to do.

Monday, October 15, 2007

Milestone Two

Tentative Title: Children’s categorization habits and the influence these behaviors have upon their Information Behavior.

Sources

  • Agosto, DE. (2002).A model of young people's decision-making in using the Web. Library & Information Science Research, 24(4), 311.
  • Bilal, D. (2005). Children's information seeking and the design of digital interfaces in the affective paradigm. Library Trends, 54(2), 197.
  • Bilal, D, (2005). Children's conceptual structures of science categories and the design of Web directories. Journal of the American Society for Information Science and Technology 1303
  • Cooper, L. Z. (2004). The socialization of information behavior: A case study of cognitive categories for library information. Library Quarterly, 74(3), 299-336.
  • Cooper, LZ. (2002). A case study of information-seeking behavior in 7-year-old children in a semistructured situation. Journal of the American Society for Information Science and Technology, 53(11), 904.
  • Cooper, L. Z. (2005). Developmentally Appropriate Digital Environments for Young Children. Library Trends, 54 (2), 286-302.
  • Druin, A (2005). What Children Can Teach Us: Developing Digital Libraries for Children with Children. The Library Quarterly, 75 (1), 20.
  • Hultgren, F., & Limberg, L. (2003). A study of research on children's information behaviour in a school context. New Review of Information Behaviour Research, 4(1), 1-15.
  • Madden, A. D., Ford, N. J., Miller, D., & Levy, P. (2006). Children's use the internet for information - seeking. Journal of Documentation, 62(6), 744-761.
  • Reuter, K., Druin, A. (2005). Bringing together children and books: An initial descriptive study of children's book searching and selection behavior in a digital library. Precedings of the American Society for Information Science and Technology, 41(1). 339-348.

Thursday, October 11, 2007

Section Six

6.3 Talja, S., Keso, H., & Pietilaminen, T. (1999). Information Processing and Management, 35. (751-763).

Context is best understood through the time and space situations of the person or items discussed. This is further expounded throughout the article as the authors attempt to elucidate the reader with the metatheoretical context of context. The authors summarize a vast majority of current theory of context and attempt to depict what context is. They employ Behaviorist and Social construction models to supplement their argument.

The authors paint a convoluted image of context throughout the article. They even suggest early on that "there is no term more often used, less often defined and, when defined; defined so variously, as context" (p. 752). I found that to be rather true, as I am unable to properly comprehend exactly what context is after reading this article. I read this article (along with the Dervin article) before and after class and still find my understanding of this concept to be lacking. I would hope with the amount of pages written on this subject it is more substantial than simply placing literature and people within their time-space situations that paint their understanding of the world. As of right now, that was all I was able to absorb from this article.

I have a problem with an article that uses slang terminology at the same time as being obnoxiously loquacious. Perhaps my problem with the fact that "context is hot" is found in both the abstract and the introduction lies within my own context of the word hot. As an American with an unfortunately large knowledge base of popular culture, I am aware of the fact that Paris Hilton uses the phrase "that's hot" more times that I would care to count. It is rumored that she even attempted to have the phrase copyrighted, thereby attempting to control all contexts of the execution of it. I am having a bit of cognitive dissonance, therefore, trying to take an article seriously that describes something as hot. The fact that, in my opinion, it spends pages of pages saying very little in an extremely large amount of words makes it worse.

Section Six

6.2 Dervin, B. (2003). Given a Context by Any Other Name: Methodological Tools for Taming the Unruly Beast. In B. Dervin & L. Foreman-Wenet (with E. Lauterbach) (Eds.). Sense-Making Methodology reader: Selected writings of Brenda Dervin (p. 111-132). Cresskill, NJ: Hampton Press.

In this particular journal entry, I am going to attempt something different than the others. Previously, I have applied the selected readings either to my life as a library user or as a future librarian. Like I stated in the journal covering the Taljn et al. readings, I am not entirely sure what context is after reading the articles twice. I plan to attend office hours sometime within the next week to better address this issue.

My difficulties with the articles on context are related to the language used to explain it. From my perspective, I believe context to be an explanation of the unique situations that surround the person or topic discussed. This seems to be what the articles say as well; but as I stated in a previous journal entry, I do not feel that context would be as "hot" as it is if that is all there is to it. There is simply something about this subject that is not penetrating my skull. So as not to be without a journal entry, I have decided to relate an example that recently happened. While it does not depict library information behavior, it does showcase information behavior from my daily life.

For years my favorite band was the Smashing Pumpkins. One of my favorite videos released by them was for the song Tonight, Tonight. There was something about the art design that really captivated me. I have not seen the video in years, and stopped thinking about it except for rare instances when I hear the song on the radio. This weekend, I had the pleasure of reading The Invention of Hugo Cabret for my Materials for Children course and found myself strongly reminded of that music video. At the end, I found the book used the film maker Georges Milies' life loosely for inspiration. I researched a bit and found the main Milies movie the book discussed, A Trip to the Moon, on Youtube. After watching it I rewatched the Smashing Pumpkins video again.

This example is the best I have to express what little I understand of context. In the sixth grade, I did not have the full scope of what artistic decisions were made, but I appreciated the video anyway. Now that I have the historical context of the Milies film, I can see that the band chose to replicate his style in their video. With this new knowledge I am better able to understand the original intent than when I had never seen Milies' movie. Prior to this information, I found this music video to be one of the best artistic representations of music to be found on Mtv; but within this new framework, I only adore it more for the allusion to one of the founders of the movie industry. Which, considering that this music video is only possible because of these movie pioneers, this makes the video more of an homage to the previous tradition than simply an entertaining clip matched to music. Without the seeking this new information, my context and understanding would never have shifted.